>> Back to: What If? Library Hub

>> Hero Maps: Golden AgeSilver Age70s 170s 280s/90s

>> Atlas Era: Heroes & MonstersRomance, Models & ComedyCRIME & WARWestern

>> Last Update: 2/15/07

 

 

WHAT IF MARVEL MASTERWORKED THEIR GOLD AND SILVER AGE CRIME AND WAR COMICS?

Welcome to the What If? Library page that joins together the two comic genres which depict the brutal heart that beats within the chest of man - when man chooses wrong over right, and when he must rise to kill an enemy combatant with his rifle, bayonet or bare hands! It's Crime and War, Masterworks fans! And one day, you may hold in your hands a book culled from the list you see to your right!

Marvel trotted out a good variety of pulpy crime books in the 40s and early 50s, and with names like Crime Can't Win, Crime Must Lose!, and Lawbreakers Always Lose!, you could be assured that the police would eventually get their man (with lots of bullets flying and blood along the way!)

For violent comics drama of a global nature, we can turn to the many war titles that Timely/Atlas produced across the 40s and 50s. If battle is your appetite, Marvel can serve up a dish to satisfy! Look at all those comics with "battle" in the title! You got yer Battle Action, Battlefield, Battlefront, and Battleground, plus Young Men on the Battlefield and Marines in Battle! And when you're ready for something a little more down to earth, there's just plain old Battle! These war anthologies served up a heavy dose of combat realism in stories written and drawn by creators who were actually there!

On top of comics dedicated to the Marines and Navy branches, the Atlas Era also saw a small but potent stable of identifiable war hero comic lines, led by Combat Casey and Combat Kelly, and including other, more obscure, men of war like Devil-Dog Dugan, Kent Blake of the Secret Service, and Sgt. Barney Barker!

It's highly unlikely we'll see any of these comics lines get the Masterworks treatment any time soon - if ever! But as usual, it's nice to muse about such things, and at the very least, this page can serve as a broad overview of what material is out there for these two genres.

-- by Gormuu

PLEASE NOTE: Many creator credits found within the maps may not be entirely accurate. Creator credits will be updated as more accurate information comes in. All maps are preliminary and subject to change.

_______________________________

GENERAL MAP OUTLINES:

All True Crime
Vol. 1: Off. True Crime Cases #24-25, ATC Cases #26-28
Vol. 2: ATC Cases #29-33
Vol. 3: ATC Cases #34, ATC #35-39
Vol. 4: ATC #40-45
Vol. 5: ATC #46-52

Amazing Detective Cases
Vol. 1: #3-14

Battle
Vol. 1: #1-10
Vol. 2: #11-20
Vol. 3: #21-30
Vol. 4: #31-40
Vol. 5: #41-50
Vol. 6: #51-60
Vol. 7: #61-70

Battle Action
Vol. 1: #1-10
Vol. 2: #11-20
Vol. 3: #21-30

Battlefield
Vol. 1: #1-11

Battlefront
Vol. 1: #1-10
Vol. 2: #11-20
Vol. 3: #21-30
Vol. 4: #31-39
Vol. 5: #40-48

Battleground
Vol. 1: #1-10
Vol. 2: #11-20

Combat
Vol. 1: #1-11

Combat Casey
Vol. 1: War Combat #1-5, Combat Casey #6-12
Vol. 2: #13-23
Vol. 3: #24-34

Combat Kelly
Vol. 1: #1-11
Vol. 2: #12-22
Vol. 3: #23-33
Vol. 4: #34-44

Complete Mystery
Vol. 1: Complete Mystery #1-4, True Complete Mystery #5-8, and Amazing Mysteries #34-35

Crime Can't Win
Vol. 1: #41-43, 4-12

Crime Cases Comics
Vol. 1: #24-27, 5-12

Crime Exposed
Vol. 1: #1, 1-6
Vol. 2: #7-14

Crimefighters
Vol. 1: #1-8
Vol. 2: #9-10, Crime Fighters #11-13

Crime Must Lose!
Vol. 1: #4-12

Devil-Dog Dugan
Vol. 1: DDD #1-3, Tales of the Marines #4, Marines At War #5-7

Justice
Vol. 1: #7-9, 4-5
Vol. 2: #6-13
Vol. 3: #14-21
Vol. 4: #22-30
Vol. 5: #31-39
Vol. 6: #40-48
Vol. 7: 49-52, Tales Of Justice #53-57
Vol. 8: Tales Of Justice #58-67

Kent Blake Of The Secret Service
Vol. 1: #1-14

Lawbreakers Always Lose
Vol. 1: #1-10

Man Comics
Vol. 1: #1-7
Vol. 2: #8-17
Vol. 3: #18-28

Marines In Action
Vol. 1: #1-14

Marines In Battle
Vol. 1: #1-13
Vol. 2: #14-25

Men's Adventure
Vol. 1: True Adventures #3, Mens Adventure #4-9
Vol. 2: #10-18
Vol. 3: #19-26

Men In Action
Vol. 1: Men In Action #1-9, Battle Brady #10-14

Navy Action
Vol. 1: #1-11
Vol. 2: Sailor Sweeney #12-14, Navy Action #15-18, Navy Tales #1-4

Navy Combat
Vol. 1: #1-10
Vol. 2: #11-20

Police Action
Vol. 1: #1-7, Casey: Crime Photographer #1-4

Private Eye
Vol. 1: #1-8

Sergeant Barney Barker
Vol. 1: SBB #1-3, GI Tales #4-6, 3-D Action #1

Sports Action
Vol. 1: Sports Stars #1, Sports Action #2-6
Vol. 2: Sports Action #7-14

Spy Cases
Vol. 1: #26-28, 4-10
Vol. 2: #11-19

Spy Fighters
Vol. 1: #1-11
Vol. 2: #12-15, Spy Thrillers #1-4, Police Badge #479 #5, Commando Adventures #1-2

War Action
Vol. 1: #1-14

War Adventures
Vol. 1: #1-13

War Comics
Vol. 1: #1-10
Vol. 2: #11-20
Vol. 3: #21-30
Vol. 4: #31-40
Vol. 5: #41-49

Young Men
Vol. 1: YM #4-11, Young Men on the Battlefield #12-13
Vol. 2: Young Men on the Battlefield #14-20, YM #21-23

 
All-True Crime Amazing Detective Cases Battle

Vol. 1
Vol. 2
Vol. 3
Vol. 4
Vol. 5

Vol. 1

Vol. 1
Vol. 2
Vol. 3
Vol. 4
Vol. 5
Vol. 6
Vol. 7

 

Battle Action Battlefield Battlefront

Vol. 1
Vol. 2
Vol. 3

Vol. 1

Vol. 1
Vol. 2
Vol. 3
Vol. 4
Vol. 5

 

Battleground Combat Comics Complete Mystery

Vol. 1
Vol. 2

Vol. 1
Combat Casey Vol. 1
Combat Casey Vol. 2
Combat Casey Vol. 3
Combat Kelly Vol. 1
Combat Kelly Vol. 2
Combat Kelly Vol. 3
Combat Kelly Vol. 4

 


Vol. 1
Crime Comics Justice Lawbreakers Must Lose

Crime Can't Win Vol. 1
Crime Cases Vol. 1
Crime Exposed Vol. 1
Crime Exposed Vol. 2
Crime Must Lose! Vol. 1
Crimefighters Vol. 1
Crimefighters Vol. 2

Vol. 1
Vol. 2
Vol. 3
Vol. 4
Vol. 5
Vol. 6
Vol. 7
Vol. 8

 


Vol. 1
Man Comics Marines Men's Adventure

Vol. 1
Vol. 2
Vol. 3

In Action Vol. 1
In Battle Vol. 1
In Battle Vol. 2

 


Vol. 1
Vol. 2
Vol. 3
Men In Action Navy Police Action

Vol. 1

Navy Action Vol. 1
Navy Action Vol. 2
Navy Combat Vol. 1
Navy Combat Vol. 2

 


Vol. 1
Private Eye Sports Action Spy Cases

Vol. 1

Vol. 1
Vol. 2

Vol. 1
Vol. 2

 

Spy Fighters War Action War Adventures

Vol. 1
Vol. 2

 


Vol. 1

Vol. 1
War Comics War Heroes Young Men

Vol. 1
Vol. 2
Vol. 3
Vol. 4
Vol. 5

 


Devil Dog Dugan V. 1
Kent Blake Vol. 1
Barney Barker Vol. 1

Vol. 1
Vol. 2
         
         
         

Website design by Doug Roberts and John Thomas. All images on this site are copyright of Marvel Comics. This site is for reference purposes and promotion of the Masterworks line of books as well as Marvel Comics and their properties.